Colorado Law Lets Parents Waive Minor's Right to Sue

by Win Gilliland, The Outdoor Network © 2003*

Colorado Senate Bill 253 was signed into law by the Governor on May 14. The new legislation expedites the legal process by making it legal for parents to release their minor’s rights to sue for negligence. Such a lawsuit could be decided in summary judgment (before trial), saving both plaintiffs and defendants significant court costs and legal fees. Currently, most courts around the country will not enforce a waiver signed by a parent on behalf of their child attempting to release the rights of their child. Consequently, most courts will allow the child to bring suit.

“Allowing a parent to release a child’s rights provides significant protection for organizations offering recreation and sport programs,” said Cathy Hansen-Stamp, co-editor of the Outdoor Education & Recreation Law Quarterly. According to co-editor Charles Gregg, parental waiver of a minor’s right to sue is currently supported by the courts in California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Ohio, and Wisconsin. Colorado, however, will be the first state to pass a law applying the doctrine specifically to general recreation. Gregg believes that the legislation will influence other states. “It is natural to assume that other states will take a second look at their policy, particularly states that have recreational interests that are well represented with their legislature,” he explained.

Anchorage-based outdoor recreation attorney Tracy Knutson agrees. “What’s happened in Colorado has sent a ripple through the entire industry,” she said. “There is no doubt that you will see this legislation in other states. We have every intent of introducing this legislature in the new session next fall, and I expect that a lot of Western states will do the same.”

Attorney Stephen Hopkins, who helped draft the original bill, said, “It might prompt recreational interests to lobby for similar legislation. This bill was successful in Colorado because an economically important group was saying ‘we want this, we need this.’”

Public policy in most states reflects the states’ interest in protecting minors, but these policies can have a detrimental effect on those who provide recreational opportunities for minors. Travis Baier, owner of Rimrock Adventures, a river outfitter based in Fruita, Colorado, notes, “We have always required both the parent and the child to sign acknowledge and assumption of risk waivers, but under the old law we still could have been sued.”

“The specter of some child coming back and suing years down the road is not a pleasant scenario,” said Tom Klema, owner of Durango-based Peregrine River Outfitters. “For outfitters, this protection comes at a very opportune time.” The insurance market is tight, and many programs, including Peregrine, have seen hikes in premiums upwards of 50 percent. “Without this added protection, we might have seen insurers refusing to cover minors and outfitters going out of business. It could have jeopardized our ability to find insurance.”

Outward Bound West Executive Director Bruce Fitch agreed. “Big insurance companies are already retreating from adventure travel and wilderness education. This legislation will help alleviate some of the pressures of finding affordable insurance, especially for smaller programs.”

For many of these small programs, even those with comprehensive insurance coverage, a lawsuit brought by a minor could spell ruin for the company. “Even though insurance would protect us from a lawsuit,” said Baier, “we would still have to close our doors. A claim like that would make it nearly impossible to find coverage.”

For David Blaine, director of programming for Mancos-based Deer Hill Expeditions, the new protection mainly translates into an added sense of security. “We are relieved to see it pass,” Blaine said, “but we aren’t going to change any of our programming based on the outcome of the bill. We will continue to run our courses as safely as possible, and like always, risk management will be a top priority.”

Outfitters are the most obvious beneficiaries of the new law, but they are not the only ones. Without protection, many outfitters might eventually have been forced to limit participation to clients over eighteen years of age. As a result, many of Colorado’s amazing recreation opportunities would be lost to a segment of the population that arguably receives the greatest benefit: minors. Jim Moss, an attorney who specializes in outdoor law, supports the legislation. “Without the ability of the parent to waive liability, children’s participation in many outdoor activities would essentially be done away with. It is an extremely important issue for children,” he said.

“It really is about options for young people,” said Fitch, who sends approximately two thousand minors into the backcountry each year. “I am all for children’s rights and looking out for the welfare of children, but under the rubric of protecting children, the old law was actually limiting a child’s opportunities.”

Hansen-Stamp noted that although children can assume risks in certain cases, they can’t enter into binding contracts to release their right to sue for negligence — or for anything else. “Recreational activities are full of inherent risks that can’t be eliminated by outfitters and those providing recreational opportunities,” she said. “There is often a gray area between whether injuries result from inherent risks (no liability) or whether they result from provider negligence (potential liability). A release, if enforced by the court, would eliminate this gray area.” Giving parents the ability to release their minors’ rights to sue means that parents must accept a greater responsibility for the risks they permit their minors to take. “Parents should take an active role in researching and choosing responsibly run programs for their children to participate in,” she said.

Melanie Mills, vice president of public policy at Colorado Ski Country USA, explained: “If you are unable to use waivers for children, over time you are going to get this hodgepodge of court decisions on what recreational providers have to do,” she said. “You are going to have providers who have insurers saying that they don’t want children participating in certain activities.” Even in the last season, Mills reports that some insurers did not want minors participating in some sorts of competitions. From their perspective, the risk was just too great.

“This is definitely a good thing for children,” agreed Blaine. “Eventually it could have reached the point where children couldn’t do anything that involves risk.”

“I don’t want any kid to die, but I wouldn’t be anywhere near the person I am today if I didn’t let my parents put me at risk,” concluded Moss. “Participating in these activities has shaped a major component of my life.”

The new law allows parents, and only parents or legal guardians, to sign a liability release for their children. With this in mind, outfitters must be administratively prepared for the inevitable scenario where a babysitter or a neighbor comes to registration to sign up a minor. Statute 13-22-107 may be read in full by searching on “253” at the Colorado General Assembly Website: www.leg.state.co.us/2003a/pubhome.nsf.

*Reprinted with permission: This article was originally printed in the Summer 2003 issue of the Outdoor Network Newsletter. It is reprinted here with permission from The Outdoor Network.

 

More About The Outdoor Network
The Outdoor Network Newsletter (ONN) is the only globally distributed publication devoted exclusively to providing news, information, and resources for outdoor recreation and adventure program directors and operators. Since 1989, the ONN has provided readers with expert opinion, insight into industry trends, and concrete tools for running an outdoor program.

For a limited time, The Outdoor Network is offering ACA members a special introductory discount on the ONN. To receive a 25 percent discount on the regular $85 subscription price, call Stephanie Guerrero at 800-688-6387 and mention that you are an ACA member.

The Outdoor Network Newsletter is published by The Outdoor Network, a business-to-business organization that serves the outdoor education and recreation industry. You can contact the author directly at win@outdoornetwork.com, and the editor Ethan Decker at editor@outdoornetwork.com.
 

Originally published in the 2003 Fall issue of The CampLine.
 

No votes yet
Tags: